Before you cook
Background Recipe story & origin
Creamy Italian dressing emerged in the 1950s when Italian American restaurants began combining mayonnaise with traditional Italian vinaigrette (olive oil, vinegar, herbs) to create a dressing that would cling better to lettuce than oil-based vinaigrettes. The technique was popularized by restaurants in New York's Little Italy and Boston's North End, where chefs needed dressings that wouldn't separate and would provide body for heartier salads. By the 1960s, commercial versions began appearing, Wish-Bone introduced Creamy Italian dressing in 1965, and by the 1970s, it was a standard grocery store item. The dressing became a home kitchen staple in the 1970s-1980s, appearing in cookbooks like 'The Joy of Cooking' (1975 edition) and 'Better Homes and Gardens New Cook Book' (1974 edition). This version follows that tradition: mayonnaise for body and cling, vinegar for tang, and Italian herbs for flavor, the creamy, tangy dressing that became an American salad standard.
Before you start Equipment you'll need
- small mixing bowl — keeps prepped ingredients organized and ready to go
- whisk — wire loops incorporate air and break up lumps better than spoons
- measuring spoons — accurate spice amounts keep flavors balanced and baking reliable
- chef's knife — sharp blade makes precise cuts for even cooking and safer prep
Safety Safety & allergen notes
- Keep refrigerated. Dressing contains dairy like components.
- Garlic intensifies over time. Use fresh and avoid over mincing.
Non-negotiables Rules for success
-
Emulsify oil slowly into vinegar base while whisking constantly.
Fast addition causes dressing to separate and break.
-
Add Italian herbs and let steep 30 minutes before serving.
Allows dried herbs to rehydrate and release flavor.
-
Shake well before each use.
Dressing separates naturally and needs re-emulsifying.
Prep Get set first
About 2 min of prep
- Prepare small mixing bowl and whisk
- Have measuring spoons ready
- Have chef's knife ready
Dressing comes together quickly. Have all ingredients measured before starting.
Ingredients
Instructions
Unlock Grouped Step Actions
Plus members get tap-to-check action steps and live ingredient swaps for this recipe.
-
Whisk the base ingredients
In mixing bowl, whisk mayonnaise, olive oil, and lemon juice until smooth.
-
Add the seasonings
Stir in garlic, dried oregano, dried basil, salt, and black pepper.
-
Thin to consistency
Whisk in tablespoon of water at a time until dressing is pourable and clings lightly to greens.
-
Serve or refrigerate
Use immediately or refrigerate up to 5 days.
Chef's notes
Designed as creamy option for House Salad.
For restaurant style version, add pinch of sugar.
For more tang, add extra teaspoon of lemon juice.
Thickens in fridge. Thin with splash of water before use.